INCOMPLETE ROHLFS–SULLIVAN ANALYSIS OF THE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF ARMORED TACTICAL WHEELED VEHICLES FOR OVERSEAS US ARMY OPERATIONS |
| |
Authors: | Franz J Gayl |
| |
Institution: | 1. Department of Plans, Policies, and Operations , Headquarters Marine Corps , Washington , D.C. , USA franz.gayl@gmail.com |
| |
Abstract: | This comment addresses the Rohlfs–Sullivan analysis titled: ‘The Cost-Effectiveness of Armored Tactical Wheeled Vehicles TWVs] for Overseas US Army Operations.’ The analysis evaluated policies to replace Type 1 and 2 TWVs with Type 3s. There is no evidence the analysis factored in fatality causes, fatality relationships to vehicles, or compared survivability of vehicles. Furthermore, it did not note when Type 3 TWVs were requested, when they impacted fatalities, or TWV use policies. It also assumed Type 3 TWVs prompted negative unit behaviors while discounting evidence of positive behaviors. In summary, the analysis is incomplete and should be revised. |
| |
Keywords: | Cost-effectiveness Mine Resistant Ambush Protected vehicle High Mobility Multi-purpose Wheeled Vehicle Operation Iraqi Freedom |
|
|